Best Carp Bait - 8 Baits to Catch More Carp Plus- Bonus Tips!

Written by Joshua in Fishing
Image Credits: Pexels.com

What’s the best carp bait you can currently use to catch more carp every time you grab the fishing poles and head to your favorite spot?

Honestly, I don’t think anyone knows..

That’s up for debate and I don’t think anyone can claim to know an exact answer to the question.

As I’ve mentioned in my other blogs, I’m no expert and get paid nothing to fish.

I just really enjoy it and want to make the experience for you more enjoyable as well.

With no black and white answer, I figured it made much more sense to give you options! A ton of options for the best carp baits are available.

We will get to that in a moment.

The species of Carp happens to be one of my personal favorites to fish for. The fight, the size, and the mental games that go into catching large carp just gets me excited each time I set out for my fishing journey.

One problem remains.

What am I using for my carp bait? What are the best carp baits that we all can use to increase our success of catching more carp?

Is there really even a best carp bait?

Tough topic because I personally haven’t tried more than about 15 different baits for catching carp.

Luckily for you, others have tried plenty of other carp baits, so I took the time to dig in and research a little further into the topic and compiled what seems to be the current top baits for catching more carp.

Let’s dive into the baits that may give you the best success for catching one of the big fellas.

Last Disclaimer- These are not listed in a ranking style. Meaning #1 listed carp bait doesn’t necessarily increase your chance of catching more carp as opposed to bait #37.

It’s simply a list of top baits I’ve researched the success of and roughly 15-20 baits that I’ve had great success with as well.

Let’s get started.

Carp Fishing And Carp Bait Best Practices

Let’s first start with some best practices for carp fishing and the baits we look at.

Carp fishing is much different than other forms of fishing such as trout fishing, crappie fishing or bass fishing.

Carp fishing is most closely related to cat fishing.

Carp are bottom feeding looking for the scum of the aqua life meals.

They feed on plant materials, vegetation and dead fish.

They are also huge fans of eating up all the random things people like you and me throw into the water.

Things, like leftover night-crawlers, fruits, seeds and yes that left-over canned corn that you should have tried one last time before giving up for the day.

It’s a patience game. “How to Catch Carp” is another blog I wrote that can help you learn and begin to understand how these fish operate under water and what they like and dislike.

If you are however familiar with the carp fishing game, let’s jump into these top baits for carp fishing.

8 of The Best Carp Baits

Bait #1: Corn

Corn is probably by the far the most popular. I don’t blame them.

It’s worked great for me in the past as well. I always used the simple sweet corn or canned corn straight from the can and onto the hook.

Why?

I don’t think anyone really has any proof on what the fish likes but most people concur that the salt and other additives make the canned corn more appealing to the carp.

Bait #2: Bread

This is growing in popularity recently but always a favorite of mine as well.

Don’t be surprised if you accidentally real in a nice channel or Flathead catfish using this bait as well.

Some people just roll the bread up into dough balls and fish under a bobber close to the bottom. Keep in mind bread will bright white, which makes it nice and easy for the

Carp also like a visual on what he’s soon to eat. Bread is also extremely visible under what and overall very versatile.

You have so many options using bread as your carp bait

You could also…

Mash Bread

Some even use other additives to increase chances of hooking into a 20lb carp.

Here’s a nice little break down for on how to mash bread for carp.

Many anglers claim adding scents and other extracts can make and ordinary carp bait turn into the best carp bait anyone has used.

Bait #3: Nightcrawlers

Is there a fish this bait won’t rank in the top 10 best baits for?

Jeeze.

Nightcrawlers were just designed to catch fish and I’ve used these slimy fella’s dozens of times to catch some of my biggest carp.

The key is to use fresh worms. You want to resemble the other critter they are use to eating on the lake and river bottoms for the greatest success.

Bait #4: Mollusk

They big key here to blend and blend well and they can work great.

If you use mollusk around other vegetation or where other living mollusks may be lurking, you fit right into the crowd which happens to be a natural carp loved entree and great area for a feeding frenzy.

Bait #5: Boilies

Wikipedia’s definition of a boilie is simply boiled paste fishing baits. Simple enough right? We thought so too. The boilies typically are composed of several ingredients that carp love such as fish meal’s, milk proteins and bird foods and sometimes flour.

I don’t believe any boilie is so much better than any other version of the boilie. They come in so many different options.

I will tell you that I believe homemade boilies tend to do much better for myself. We will cover the homemade carp baits later in this post.

Bait #6: Paste Pellets

Really any kind of pellet could work to catch carp, but the paste pellets seem to really work for me.

This is also a tricky bait. I’ve had some issues with keeping these rigged up due to size and other small fish constantly going after it.

They also diffuse or dissolve quickly in the water so if you’re a non-patient person this works great due to checking your bait frequently and reapplying to the hook.

I’d go far enough to say that your best method is doubling up to keep the little fellas away from your hook.

Bait #7: Hemp Seeds

Hemp tends to bring in plenty of fish. At least In my experience.

What seemed to happen was, while fishing for carp, I’d typically catch other species of fish as well.

The juices need to stay around, however, don’t discard any of the extra juice if you are making your own. This is what releases your main attractants to being in those larger carp.

The juice just helps send off better bait signals, and scents making it a leader in the pack for the best carp bait.

Bait #8: All Artificial Baits for Carp

It’s a common myth that cheap artificial baits don’t work. Let me be the first to tell you, they do, and they work well if used properly.

Lures for catching carp could fall into this category. You just need to put a little creative thinking to the problem to find your perfect mix with artificial baits.

Small plastic grubs or worms can work great. The goal with these lures is to get them down to the mud at the bottom of the water as quickly as possible.

Jigs For Carps

Jigs can also be a good option for carp fishing. The jigs need to be used in a manner that drags the bottom. Only common carp will likely be attracted to these jigs, but you do have a chance at a grass carp from striking from time to time.

The Good Ol’ Artificial Flies For Carp

Carp flies are often overlooked as a good bait for catching carp. Carp is a tough species of fish to catch so trying a variety of different baits and methods is key. I haven’t had as much success with artificial flies as I have other baits on this list, however, I have had luck.

There is a huge variety of artificial flies available.

My honest opinion is for you to just try them all out and see what works best for you. I don’t think anyone can claim they have the secret fly that works each time they go out.

If you do however have the luck, comment in the area’s below because I’d love to hear about any additional tips and tricks to catching more of these big fellas.

Homemade Baits Work Great

We have covered some of the baits that you can purchase or use easily with a store purchase or even ordering online right from Amazon.

What we haven’t covered is throwing on an apron and making your own. It’s been a large niche area of fishing for a long time.

The biggest reason why it’s such a desired path is that it works fantastic. For Carp and Catfish (the two species I fish for most frequently).

Let’s dive into the best homemade carp baits to try immediately!

Full transparency.

I’ve only made 2 of these homemade baits. I have however made them dozens of times and always had great success with catching carp 5-20lbs in size.

More transparency. My mom started me on the first bait at a very young age by making it for me.

It worked, so it continued after I got old enough to make my way around a kitchen on my own.

Peanut Butter Combo Ball

Now I did some digging on this homemade bait on what others have had success with and my own success with this bait. The first key to remember with this bait, it will attract catfish as well. If you don’t want to that, try a different bait method.

  • Here is an easy recipe for Carp
  • Peanut Butter Combo Ball-
  • Peanut Butter
  • Flour
  • Water
  • Sugar

I use Sea Salt as well (not sure if this helps but I have caught carp with it)

The key is to get some flour into the mix to a point that the bait hardens up a bit and allows it to stay strong under water. If it’s too soft, you will just feed the carp but never set the hook.

Use a mixing pan to stir these ingredients together until you get the correct consistency. This recipe can also be frozen until a later use. Just make sure to thaw out the night before use to make sure it’s ready to go.

The Cereal Breakfast Ball-

Many fishermen use different variations for this homemade carp bait as well. I’ve found the following recipe to work well.

  • Any cereal- ¾ cup (preferably Wheaties but 1 cup is okay as well)
  • Flour
  • 1/5 Cup of sugar or brown sugar
  • Any color aid to brighten up the ball.

(Bright colors work best such as red, yellow or orange. You can use Kool-aide, lemon juice, or other artificial flavoring tools)

The Wildcard Best Carp Bait

  • Yellow Corn Flour
  • White Flour
  • Water
  • Sugar
  • Peanut Butter
  • Shredded Wheat

Follow the steps below:

  1. Pour 2 cups of yellow corn flour into a container.
  2. Add the white flour
  3. Add the half cup of sugar
  4. Mix all together which a whisk or wooden spoon
  5. Add Water until you can form a ball with the mix.
  6. Roll the mixture into a ball or cubes
  7. Boil them for 45-60 minutes on low heat.
  8. Remove balls and add the peanut butter-
  9. Added the shredded wheat to the outer part of the ball
  10. Go cast and catch plenty of carp.

So, there you have it.

I’m sure plenty of great carp baits are out there and being used but these are my personal recommendations and baits

Other methods carp fishing won’t even require any of these top carp baits to be used such as bowfishing for carp and fly fishing for carp.

I’ve had success with.

As stated in many other blogs,

I’m no Carp expert and don’t get paid to catch to them but I do find giving others the chance to catch more carp to be enjoyable.

So, what is the best carp bait? I really don’t know. I don’t think anyone does.

If you feel the best carp bait was left off this list and needs to be added or have had success with something completely different, please comment below for all of us to know so we can all enjoy catching more these carp on every fishing trip we take.

Till Next time.

About Joshua
My name i Joshua, and i am one of the authors on BonFireBob - I especially like fishing and gear.

Related posts
Fishing
I was watching a nature documentary recently that featured both Beluga whales and Northern Pike, and it sparked my curiosity about the two species. So, I did some research of my own to make a connection between the two animals and find out if they have an
Fishing
When I was reading about the diets of pikeminnow on the internet recently after finding out that they eat other fish, I began to wonder how much they can really consume in just one day. So, I did some more digging to determine the average amounts of smolt
Fishing
The Arctic Grayling is a unique species of fish that is most commonly found in Arctic and Pacific drainages throughout the world. Commonly fished for sport, these aquatic creatures were introduced to new bodies of freshwater in the early 20th century for
Fishing
During my research of pikeminnow fishing, I started to wonder if people eat them and what they taste like. After discovering that these fish are, indeed, edible, I was curious to find out more details about the dish. So, I did some more research and put a