10 Best Carp Bait Comparison – Baits to Catch More Carp

10 Best Carp Bait Comparison – Baits to Catch More Carp

At BonfireBob, I recommend products based on unbiased research, but I will earn a commission if you shop through the links on this page.

What’s the best carp bait you can currently use to catch more carp every time you grab the fishing poles and head to your favorite spot?

That’s up for debate and I don’t think anyone can claim to know an exact answer to the question.

I Aim to Find the Best Carp Baits

For me, the best carp bait doesn’t have to be the most expensive. It’s the one that matches YOUR needs.

In order to help you find the perfect fit for you I break up the carp bait buying advice as:

Best value for money (price, performance and quality)

The links is affiliate-links meaning I get a small commission if your purchase. It’s what keeps my blog up and running.

#1: Xhope Corn Carp Fishing Lures

best carp bait to catch more carp

Where I’ve found the best price:

Pros:

  • Look, smell, and feel like real sweet corn pieces
  • Used in any type of water
  • Made with environmentally-friendly and recyclable TPR
  • Used successfully on a hair rig

Cons:

  • Floating strength does not hold heavy, carp hook on their own
  • Somewhat expensive for small pieces of corn

This bait is designed to look, and smell, like sweet corn. The lifelike appearance, softness, and realistic, sweet-corn smell attract fish to bite, especially carp.

While they may seem a tad on the pricey side, these corn lures are high in quality and sure to increase your number of bites.  Your purchase includes a pack of 30 pieces of “corn.” 

These lures can be used in any type of water: fresh and saltwater, ponds, lakes, rivers, or oceans. These corn pieces are made for those who like to DIY their own lures.

Many users mention that the corn, while it is able to float, is not strong enough to hold a premium, heavy carp hook.  Seasoned carp fishermen use these lures on a hair rig with great success.

In addition to being useful and effective, these Corn Carp Fishing Lures are made with environmentally-friendly thermoplastic rubber (TPR) material, which is reusable for long periods of time and recyclable when it is no longer usable. 

#2: Berkley Gulp! Extruded Nightcrawlers

best carp bait to catch more carp

Where I’ve found the best price:

  • Amazon with worldwide shipping

Pros:

  • Realistic look, smell, and feel
  • Durable and long-lasting
  • Biodegradable and made with natural ingredients

Cons:

  • Users complain that the bait is too “soft,” allowing fish to take bites out of the artificial bait

The Berkley Gulp! Extruded Nightcrawlers are artificial nightcrawlers that have the look, smell, and feel of the real thing.  Their design is made to imitate the natural curves of a real nightcawler, in addition to their taste and feel.

The smell of a Berkley Gulp! Extruded Nightcrawler is so potent that it leaves a scent trail that fish can track from very long distances.  They are realistically engineered to help you catch more fish, no matter the environment or situation.

This artificial bait can be dangled from floats, rigged like worms, or used any other way that nightcrawlers are used.

Your purchase of a 2.5 ounce jar of Berkley Gulp! Extruded Nightcrawlers gets you 12 crawlers that are each six inches long.  These artificial nightcrawlers are made to last for a long time, so you will not have to constantly replace your bait.

They are also natural and biodegradable so they are safe for the environment in case they are lost in the water.

#3: Tbest Carp Bait Foam Pop-Up Pellets

best-carp-bait

Where I’ve found the best price:

  • Amazon with worldwide shipping

Pros:

  • Lightweight and buoyant
  • Inexpensive
  • Brightly colored
  • Sweet potato flavor

Cons:

  • Does not pop up well
  • Not environmentally friendly

Next on our list is the Tbest Carp Bait Foam Pop-Up Pellets.  These foam pellets are soft, and look like boilies, but they are artificial. The foam makes them extremely buoyant, so that they suspend your hook nicely in the water, working perfectly with a hair rig.

The buoyancy is strong enough to float other types of pill bait, live, bait, or even corn grains.  The foam material also makes them super lightweight, and easy to use and carry around. 

In addition to being bright orange in color, these Tbest Carp Bait Foam Pop-Up Pellets taste like sweet potato, making them more enticing to fish.

The sweet potato flavor leaves a scent behind in the water as well, so fish can track the trail of scent from a distance.

This order includes 30 pieces of orange, sweet potato-flavored foam pellets that are each 12mm in diameter.

#4: Berkley Gulp! Earthworm

best carp bait to catch more carp

Where I’ve found the best price:

  • Amazon with worldwide shipping

Pros:

  • Inexpensive
  • Realistic look, touch, smell, and feel
  • Extreme scent dispersion

Cons:

  • Line on label mentions risk of “cancer or reproductive” issues
  • Does not work as well as real earthworms

Another product from the Berkley Gulp! company is their Earthworm bait.  This bait has a few similarities to the Berkley Gulp! Nightcrawler bait previously described, but the bait are earthworms instead.

These earthworms are life-like in look, scent, and touch, and are made using the highest-quality materials.

These earthworms make great bait for a wide variety of fish, so they are great to have on-hand no matter what type of fish you plan to catch.  These Berkley Gulp! Earthworms are brown in color and 4-inches in size.

Special features for this bait include extreme scent dispersion, affordable price, and its ability to biodegrade. It has 400 times more scent dispersion than regular artificial bait.

Users mention that this jar of earthworms lasts for a long time as they can typically stay on the fish for 2-3 fish. Some users even mention cutting each worm in half to make their purchase go even further.

#5: Phecda Sport Boilies Eggs

best carp bait to catch more carp

Where I’ve found the best price:

  • Amazon with worldwide shipping

Pros:

  • Multiple color and flavor combinations
  • Leaves behind odor in water
  • Made of lightweight and buoyant foam

Cons:

  • Different color/flavor combos have different success rates
  • Not environmentally friendly

Another type of artificial boilies is the Phecda Sport Boilies Eggs.  These eggs come in four different colors and flavors for you to choose from. Each flavor comes in a jar with 30 pieces, each 12 millimeters in diameter.

Flavors and colors to choose from are green with an apple flavor, orange with a sweet potato flavor, red with a strawberry flavor, or yellow with a sweet corn flavor. Each scent leaves behind a strong odor in the water for fish to follow and find easily, greatly increasing your rate of catching fish.

These Phecda Sport Boilies are made specifically for carp fishing. They are made of a foam-like material which makes them float easily and pop-up quickly in the water.  

Users mention that this artificial bait stays on your hook well and can be reused multiple times.

#6: Kodiak Fish Attractant Paste

best carp bait to catch more carp

Where I’ve found the best price:

  • Amazon with worldwide shipping

Pros:

  • Can be used on any type of lure
  • Multiple formulas offered for different types of fish
  • Potent to attract fish
  • Adheres well to lure

Cons:

  • One tube does not last very long

Kodiak Fish Attractant Paste is a little different than the other products that have been on our list so far.  This fish attractant is made from different kinds of all-natural baitfish, and that’s it!

There are no extra chemicals or additives in the Kodiak formula, just freeze-dried baitfish.  Freeze-drying the baitfish maintains the flavor so that the taste of the paste is strong and appealing to fish.

The Kodiak Fish Attractant Paste comes in different formulas to attract different kinds of fish.

Choose between: Alwife, Bass, Catfish, Crayfish, Minnow, Nightcrawler, Shad, Smelt, or Walleye.  

To apply, simply squeeze the paste onto your lure.  It will help you attract more fish from long distances and increase the number of bites that you get.  This paste adheres well to any type of lure or bait.

#7: Mighty Seed Hemp Seeds

best carp bait to catch more carp

Where I’ve found the best price:

  • Amazon with worldwide shipping

Pros:

  • Successful with many types of fish
  • Inexpensive
  • Last a long time

Cons:

  • Require preparation in order to use

While this seems like another unique item on our list, hemp seeds are a very popular and common type of bait.

Hemp seeds are one of the most universally successful coarse fishing baits that works well for Carp, Barbel, Tench, Chub, Roach, and more.

These Mighty Seed Hemp Hulled Seeds are the perfect fishing hemp. They have a slightly nutty taste, and puff up nicely when cooked.

Hemp seeds are great bait to use, however they are not ready to use when you purchase them.  First, you have to boil them in water.

When they are boiled, they will soften, puff up, and split open.  Then, they can all be frozen and stored until your next fishing trip.

#8: Dovewill Floating Fishing Lures

best-carp-bait

Where I’ve found the best price:

  • Amazon with worldwide shipping

Pros:

  • 14 mm in diameter
  • Multiple flavor and color combinations
  • Soft, flexible, lightweight material that is non-poisonous to fish

Cons:

  • Users complain that the material is toolight and not durable enough

Dovewill Floating Fishing Lures are soft and lightweight artificial boilies.  They are made of a nano-material that is non-poisonous to fish. These boilies float well in the water, and pop-up well after casting.

They come in three traditional color and flavor combinations: orange sweet potato, red strawberry, and green apple.

These flavors penetrate the water and leave their strong scent behind so that fish can find them quickly and easily.  

The nano-material that the Dovewill Floating Fish Lures are made of makes them flexible for great performance in the water.  This material also makes them very easy to attach to your hook, no matter what kind you are using.

These artificial boilies stay put also, and do not fall off easily, so they can be re-used multiple times.  At 14 mm in diameter, these are the largest boilies on our list. They come at 12 pieces per box.   

#9: OriGlam Fake Corn Bait

best carp bait to catch more carp

Where I’ve found the best price:

  • Amazon with worldwide shipping

Pros:

  • Inexpensive
  • Multiple colors and many pieces
  • Smell, look, and feel like real sweet corn
  • Can be used in many types of water

Cons:

  • Do not float well

OriGlam Fake Corn Bait comes with 125 pieces of different colored fake corn.  These artificial pieces of corn are the same size and shape as a real piece of sweet corn.  In addition to looking like corn, they have the taste of sweet corn also.

The material used to make OriGlam Fake Corn Bait is high quality, durable, and non-toxic for the fish.

The combination of the look, taste, and feel attract more fish, leading to more bites for you!  

When you purchase OriGlam Fake Corn Bait, you get a mixture of pink, green, orange, red, and traditional yellow artificial corn bait.

All 125 pieces come organized nicely in their own tackle box. This bait is made to be used in many different types of water: freshwater, saltwater, rivers, lakes, or ponds. 

#10: Strawberry Tiger Nuts in Liquid

best carp bait to catch more carp

Where I’ve found the best price:

  • Amazon with worldwide shipping

Pros:

  • Pre-prepared and ready to use
  • Strawberry flavored
  • Stay on well
  • Can be used with other types of bait as well

Cons:

  • Cannot be used with hooks

The last item on our list comes from the Wicked Carp Company, a popular and reputable company that provides many different kinds of bait.  These Strawberry Tiger Nuts are made specifically for carp fishing.

Typical tiger nuts need to be prepared ahead of time, similar to hemp seeds.  These tiger nuts, however, have been prepared for you. They come suspended in liquid for freshness, and are ready to use straight from the jar.  

These tiger nuts go through a preparation process to ensure they are fish-friendly.  The strawberry flavoring is potent for immediate attraction upon entry into the water.

These tiger nuts can be used with other types of bait, including corn and boilies.  The only thing that you need to know before purchasing is that they are not made to be used with hooks.

They are made to work best with hair rigs, and stay put, even when casting long distances.

Carp Bait Buyer’s Guide

When it comes to shopping for bait, it is important to consider your preferences for a few necessary qualities before making your final choice.   

Type of Fish 

When considering what bait to purchase, it is necessary to first make a decision about what type of fish you plan to catch.

Certain bait is meant for particular types of fish, while other bait works well for many different species.  This also includes the type of water you will be fishing in.

Some types of bait are for saltwater, while some are for freshwater.

Do your research ahead of time so that you know what will be the best choice. 

Carp Bait Flavoring 

Another thing to consider is if you’d like to use bait that is artificially flavored, or has no flavor at all.

Some fishermen prefer their bait to have strong flavor that leaves a trail in the water for fish to follow.

Others like to rely on other skills to attract their fish.  Whichever you prefer, there is both flavored and non-flavored bait for you to choose from.  

The Price of the Carp Bait

As with any product you search for, it is necessary to consider the price of your bait.  What are you willing to spend?

When thinking about the answer to this question, you will have to take a look at the overall price and compare it to the pieces of bait that are included in your purchase.

Consider their durability and ability to be reused as well, as this has an effect on the overall price per piece of bait.

Homemade Baits Work Great

We have covered some of the baits that you can purchase or use easily with a store purchase or even ordering online right from Amazon.

What we haven’t covered is throwing on an apron and making your own. It’s been a large niche area of fishing for a long time.

The biggest reason why it’s such a desired path is that it works fantastic. For Carp and Catfish (the two species I fish for most frequently).

Let’s dive into the best homemade carp baits to try immediately!

Full transparency.

I’ve only made 2 of these homemade baits. I have however made them dozens of times and always had great success with catching carp 5-20lbs in size.

More transparency. My mom started me on the first bait at a very young age by making it for me.

It worked, so it continued after I got old enough to make my way around a kitchen on my own.

Peanut Butter Combo Ball

Now I did some digging on this homemade bait on what others have had success with and my own success with this bait. The first key to remember with this bait, it will attract catfish as well. If you don’t want to that, try a different bait method.

  • Here is an easy recipe for Carp
  • Peanut Butter Combo Ball-
  • Peanut Butter
  • Flour
  • Water
  • Sugar

I use Sea Salt as well (not sure if this helps but I have caught carp with it)

The key is to get some flour into the mix to a point that the bait hardens up a bit and allows it to stay strong under water. If it’s too soft, you will just feed the carp but never set the hook.

Use a mixing pan to stir these ingredients together until you get the correct consistency. This recipe can also be frozen until a later use. Just make sure to thaw out the night before use to make sure it’s ready to go.

The Cereal Breakfast Ball

Many fishermen use different variations for this homemade carp bait as well. I’ve found the following recipe to work well.

  • Any cereal- ¾ cup (preferably Wheaties but 1 cup is okay as well)
  • Flour
  • 1/5 Cup of sugar or brown sugar
  • Any color aid to brighten up the ball.

(Bright colors work best such as red, yellow or orange. You can use Kool-aide, lemon juice, or other artificial flavoring tools)

The Wildcard Best Carp Bait

  • Yellow Corn Flour
  • White Flour
  • Water
  • Sugar
  • Peanut Butter
  • Shredded Wheat

Follow the steps below:

  1. Pour 2 cups of yellow corn flour into a container.
  2. Add the white flour
  3. Add the half cup of sugar
  4. Mix all together which a whisk or wooden spoon
  5. Add Water until you can form a ball with the mix.
  6. Roll the mixture into a ball or cubes
  7. Boil them for 45-60 minutes on low heat.
  8. Remove balls and add the peanut butter-
  9. Added the shredded wheat to the outer part of the ball
  10. Go cast and catch plenty of carp.

So, there you have it.

I’m sure plenty of great carp baits are out there and being used but these are my personal recommendations and baits

Other methods carp fishing won’t even require any of these top carp baits to be used such as bowfishing for carp and fly fishing for carp.

I’ve had success with.

As stated in many other blogs,

I’m no Carp expert and don’t get paid to catch to them but I do find giving others the chance to catch more carp to be enjoyable.

So, what is the best carp bait? I really don’t know. I don’t think anyone does.

If you feel the best carp bait was left off this list and needs to be added or have had success with something completely different, please comment below for all of us to know so we can all enjoy catching more these carp on every fishing trip we take.

All Carp Baits Have Pros And Cons

They all have pros and cons but all of these recommendations are relatively cheap and easy on the wallet. None of them will steer you wrong but do need to be used in the correct situations and applications to make them work effectively. If you are looking for other related carp fishing gear, be sure to check out my other main page for my other recommendations and top picks.

Do you believe any more baits need added to the list? Any thoughts or questions? Be sure to leave a comment below. I’d love to hear from you and as always!

Jigs can also be a good option for carp fishing. The jigs need to be used in a manner that drags the bottom. Only common carp will likely be attracted to these jigs, but you do have a chance at a grass carp from striking from time to time.

* Pin it for later *,

Best carp bait. What’s the best carp bait you can currently use to catch more carp every time you grab the fishing poles and head to your favorite spot? Get my favorits here! #carpfish #carpbait #bestcarpbait #carpfishing #carpfish #fishingcarp #fishingforcarp #carpfishingbeginner #carptrick #carpfishingtrick #catchcarp #carpcatching #carpbaitbest #carpcorn #carpnightcrawlers #popupbait #earthwormbait #boiliesbait #fishinglure #floatingfishinglure

Disclaimer

As I’ve mentioned in my other posts, I’m no expert and get paid nothing to fish.

I just really enjoy it and want to make the experience for you more enjoyable as well.

With no black and white answer, I figured it made much more sense to give you options! A ton of options for the best carp baits are available.

The species of Carp happens to be one of my personal favorites to fish for. The fight, the size, and the mental games that go into catching large carp just gets me excited each time I set out for my fishing journey.

One problem remains.

What am I using for my carp bait? What are the best carp baits that we all can use to increase our success of catching more carp?

Is there really even a best carp bait?

Tough topic because I personally haven’t tried more than about 15 different baits for catching carp.

Luckily for you, others have tried plenty of other carp baits, so I took the time to dig in and research a little further into the topic and compiled what seems to be the current top baits for catching more carp.

Let’s dive into the baits that may give you the best success for catching one of the big fellas.

Last Disclaimer- These are not listed in a ranking style. Meaning #1 listed carp bait doesn’t necessarily increase your chance of catching more carp as opposed to bait #37.

It’s simply a list of top baits I’ve researched the success of and roughly 15-20 baits that I’ve had great success with as well.

Carp Fishing And Carp Bait Best Practices

Let’s first start with some best practices for carp fishing and the baits we look at.

Carp fishing is much different than other forms of fishing such as trout fishing, crappie fishing or bass fishing.

Carp fishing is most closely related to cat fishing.

Carp are bottom feeding looking for the scum of the aqua life meals.

They feed on plant materials, vegetation and dead fish.

They are also huge fans of eating up all the random things people like you and me throw into the water.

Things, like leftover night-crawlers, fruits, seeds and yes that left-over canned corn that you should have tried one last time before giving up for the day.

It’s a patience game. “How to Catch Carp” is another blog I wrote that can help you learn and begin to understand how these fish operate under water and what they like and dislike.

If you are however familiar with the carp fishing game, let’s jump into these top baits for carp fishing.

Be sure to know the difference between summer carp bait and winter carp bait.

* Pin it for later *

Best carp bait. What’s the best carp bait you can currently use to catch more carp every time you grab the fishing poles and head to your favorite spot? Get my favorits here! #carpfish #carpbait #bestcarpbait #carpfishing #carpfish #fishingcarp #fishingforcarp #carpfishingbeginner #carptrick #carpfishingtrick #catchcarp #carpcatching #carpbaitbest #carpcorn #carpnightcrawlers #popupbait #earthwormbait #boiliesbait #fishinglure #floatingfishinglure
Join the discussion

Newsletter

Make sure to subscribe to our newsletter and be the first to know the news.